Understanding Civil Penalties for Immigration Violations
The Department of Homeland Security (DHS) and the Department of Justice (DOJ) have finalized a rule concerning civil penalties for certain immigration violations. This rule, which took effect on October 14, 2026, outlines the procedures for assessing and collecting these penalties. While the rule does not change the amounts of the penalties, it introduces a limited exception for late appeals in cases where mail delays were beyond a person’s control. This analysis will break down who is covered by the rule, what penalties can apply, and how individuals can appeal a penalty.
Who is Subject to Civil Penalties?
The final rule, issued by U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE), DHS, and the Executive Office for Immigration Review (EOIR), specifies three main groups of individuals who may face civil penalties:
Individuals with a Final Removal Order
This category includes people who have received a final order to leave the United States and willfully fail or refuse to depart. It also covers individuals who take actions to prevent their departure or removal. A penalty is not issued if there is a legal pause, known as a stay, or a qualifying protection that allows the person to remain in the U.S.
Individuals Failing to Meet Voluntary Departure Deadlines
When an Immigration Judge or the Board of Immigration Appeals (BIA) orders a person to leave the U.S. by a specific date, failure to do so can result in a civil penalty. The penalty amount is set within an inflation-adjusted range of $1,992 to $9,970, with a default of $3,000 if no specific amount is stated in the order.
Individuals Apprehended During Unlawful Entry
Customs and Border Protection (CBP) can assess a penalty for individuals apprehended while entering or attempting to enter the United States unlawfully. This applies if the apprehension occurs within seven days of the unlawful entry or attempted entry, and before the individual reaches their intended destination.
It is important to note that individuals who present themselves at a port of entry to seek asylum or other protection are not subject to penalties under this rule. However, simply entering unlawfully with the intent to seek asylum does not automatically exempt someone from potential penalties.
Types and Amounts of Civil Penalties
The penalties vary depending on the specific violation:
- Failure to Depart After a Final Removal Order: The maximum penalty for this violation is $998 for each day the individual remains in noncompliance. DHS typically aims to assess the maximum penalty allowed, within legal time limits.
- Failure to Depart Within a Voluntary Departure Order: As mentioned, the penalty for this falls between $1,992 and $9,970, with $3,000 as the standard amount.
- Unlawful Entry: Penalties for unlawful entry range from $100 to $500 for each instance of entry or attempted entry.
The rule also outlines lookback periods for these penalties. For failure-to-depart penalties, the penalty can cover violations up to five years prior to the decision. Voluntary-departure penalties are assessed if the departure period expired within the last five years. Unlawful-entry penalties are for apprehensions within the preceding five years.
How to Appeal a Civil Penalty
Individuals facing a civil penalty have the right to appeal the decision. The process requires a written appeal to be filed and postmarked within 15 business days after the initial penalty decision is served. The DHS can serve decisions in person or by mail, with service considered complete upon mailing. If a timely appeal is not filed, the initial decision becomes final.
The Appeal Process
Appeals can only be made to DHS, not to the BIA. The initial appeal consists of a written notice, and supporting arguments or evidence are not required at this stage. A DHS supervisory officer will review the appeal, considering the matter anew. A final decision must be issued within 45 days. While a timely appeal is pending, the initial penalty decision is put on hold. Individuals have the option to have legal representation at their own expense.
Late Appeals and Exceptions
DHS may accept a late appeal if the individual provides a written explanation and evidence demonstrating that mail delivery delays were beyond their control. This is decided on a case-by-case basis. For failure-to-depart penalties, evidence of circumstances beyond an individual’s control, such as being unable to obtain travel documents, hospitalization, or incarceration, can be presented.
Other Consequences and Considerations
Beyond financial penalties, failing to comply with a voluntary-departure order can lead to ineligibility for certain forms of relief for up to 10 years. This includes cancellation of removal and adjustment of status. While the statutes do not grant a right to seek a reduction in penalties, DHS has the discretion to reopen a decision and reduce or waive a fine. Notably, DHS policy is to waive failure-to-depart penalties for non-criminal individuals who schedule their departure through the CBP Home app and leave the United States.
The final rule largely adopts the procedures from an interim final rule issued in June 2025, with the key modification being the allowance for late appeals due to documented mail delays. The rule does not expand the types of violations covered or alter the minimum or maximum penalty amounts. A federal court had previously placed a stay on certain penalties issued under the interim rule for individuals with voluntary-departure or final removal orders between June 27, 2025, and October 13, 2026. These penalties are distinct from those issued under the new final rule. The DOJ plans to conduct a thorough review of penalties in 2027.
Frequently Asked Questions
Who is subject to civil penalties for immigration violations?
Civil penalties can apply to individuals with a final removal order who don’t leave, those who miss voluntary departure deadlines, and individuals apprehended during unlawful entry.
What are the penalty amounts for failing to depart the U.S.?
For failure to depart after a final removal order, the penalty is up to $998 per day. For missing a voluntary departure deadline, the penalty is between $1,992 and $9,970, with $3,000 being the default.
Can I appeal a civil penalty decision?
Yes, you have the right to appeal. A written appeal must be filed and postmarked within 15 business days of the decision. The appeal is reviewed by a DHS supervisory officer.
Are there any exceptions for late appeals?
DHS may accept a late appeal if you provide proof that mail delays were beyond your control. Other circumstances beyond your control, like hospitalization, may also be considered.

Conversation
0 Comments