ICE Detention Expansion Criticized by GAO for Lack of Strategic Planning

The U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) has seen a significant rise in its detention population, reaching approximately 67,200 individuals by July 2026. This growth occurred without a clear, comprehensive strategic plan, according to a report by the Government Accountability Office (GAO). The GAO’s findings highlight a concerning trend of expansion driven by funding increases, rather than a well-defined approach to detention capacity, long-term costs, and alternative solutions.

GAO Faults ICE for Expansion Without a Strategic Framework

A report released by the Government Accountability Office (GAO) on September 24, 2026, criticized U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) for its rapid expansion of detention facilities. The GAO found that the agency’s detention population increased by 71 percent, from about 39,300 in January 2025 to nearly 67,200 by July 2026. This growth was largely fueled by congressional funding, including $45 billion allocated through the One Big Beautiful Bill Act, intended for detention capacity expansion. However, the GAO report, titled “Urgent Planning Needed to Avoid Further Waste of Taxpayer Dollars,” pointed out that ICE initiated six detention projects without establishing consistent goals for bed capacity or the specific characteristics of those beds.

Insufficient Assessment of Costs and Alternatives

The GAO’s review revealed that ICE had not adequately assessed the long-term costs and risks associated with different types of detention facilities. A proper strategic plan, the GAO stated, should connect agency objectives with specific activities and resource needs, including milestones to track progress. This analysis would enable ICE to compare new facilities with existing options within its traditional detention network. Instead, the agency invested over $2.5 billion in warehouses and other facilities without sufficient information to determine their long-term affordability. This lack of thorough assessment led to financial losses, including over $20 million in costs related to abandoned or scaled-back warehouse purchases.

Documented Waste in Facility Spending and Supplies

Beyond the strategic planning failures, the GAO report detailed instances of significant waste. ICE acquired 11 warehouses for detention use, only to later decide to sell seven of them, resulting in substantial losses. Further examples of waste included $7.1 million spent on unneeded food at a Texas detention site and nearly $3 million worth of tents that remained unused at Guantánamo Bay. The plans for Guantánamo had once envisioned housing 30,000 individuals, yet the average daily detained population there was only 16 in fiscal year 2026. These figures underscore a broader concern that ICE’s facility choices were not adequately tested against actual needs.

DHS Commits to a 2027 Deadline for a Strategic Plan

In response to the GAO’s recommendations, the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) has stated that ICE will deliver a strategic plan or a similar document by August 31, 2027. This timeline was communicated by David Schmitt, the department’s director of the Departmental Audit Liaison Office, in a letter dated September 15, 2026. However, the GAO expressed concerns that this schedule might not be timely enough to prevent continued waste of taxpayer dollars. The watchdog warned that given the substantial, multi-year funding for detention, a more rapid completion of the plan could be warranted. The DHS’s agreement signifies acceptance of the recommendation, but the GAO remains watchful about the potential for ongoing spending before ICE establishes a clear framework for evaluating its investments.

Lawmakers Criticize “Reckless Expansion” Amidst Planning Gaps

Heather MacLeod, GAO’s director of Homeland Security and Justice, characterized the situation as a broad failure in planning, describing the process as marked by “stops and starts.” This sentiment was echoed by lawmakers. On September 24, 2026, Senators Gary Peters, Dick Durbin, and Jack Reed issued a statement calling the report’s findings evidence of “reckless expansion.” They also criticized ICE’s planning document as being little more than a spreadsheet. While GAO recommendations are not legally binding, their findings can significantly influence congressional oversight, budget allocations, and an agency’s future planning efforts as lawmakers consider the ongoing expansion of detention capabilities. The GAO’s warning emphasizes that without improved planning, ICE risks making continued uninformed decisions, leading to inefficiency and the squandering of public funds.

Frequently Asked Questions