Skip to content
Open menu
Toggle search

ICE Found in Contempt for Re-detaining Habeas Petitioners in Colorado

Share

ICE Found in Contempt for Re-detaining Habeas Petitioners in Colorado

SA Portal

SA Portal

Published
Share

Judge Finds ICE in Contempt for Re-Detaining Colorado Habeas Petitioners

On November 18, 2026, U.S. District Judge Charlotte N. Sweeney ruled that U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) officials were in contempt of court. This finding came after ICE re-detained Ramon Quintero Alvarez immediately following a court order for his release. ICE is the federal agency responsible for enforcing immigration laws in the United States. Habeas petitioners are individuals who ask a court to review the legality of their detention.

Advertisements

The court determined that the contempt lasted from October 27 until November 9, 2026, when ICE stopped the practice of re-detaining these individuals. ICE Acting Field Office Director Nathan Rasper provided a sworn commitment to the court that ICE would no longer re-detain habeas petitioners who were ordered released in the District of Colorado. Because ICE ceased this practice, the judge decided not to take further action, effectively resolving the contempt finding.

Who the Court’s Commitment Covers

The commitment made by ICE specifically applies to habeas petitioners within the District of Colorado who have received a court order for their release. The U.S. District Court for the District of Colorado is the primary federal trial court for this region. By November 9, 2026, ICE had stopped the immediate re-detention of these individuals. Rasper assured the court that this practice would not resume in the district.

Advertisements

Subscribe for updates

Get new posts, insights, and occasional updates delivered to your inbox.

We respect your privacy.

How Ramon Quintero Alvarez’s Case Unfolded

The events leading to the contempt finding began on October 20, 2026. On this date, Judge Sweeney ordered the government to respond to Alvarez’s petition and provide a reason by October 27 why the court should not grant his release. If the government failed to meet this deadline, the order stipulated that Alvarez should be released within 24 hours, with a status report to follow within seven days. A status report is an update filed with the court regarding the progress of a case.

See also  ACLU Lawsuit Challenges ICE's Use of WRAP Restraint Device

On October 27, Rasper testified that he had initiated the policy of immediate rearrest in the District of Colorado. He instructed deputy field office directors to review cases subject to release with ICE’s Office of Principal Legal Advisor, which is ICE’s legal department. The directive was to check for any restrictions on rearrest before proceeding with release and subsequent re-detention. The government later reported that Alvarez was released on October 27 but was immediately re-detained.

By November 3, the government filed a status report confirming that Alvarez had been released on October 27, immediately re-detained, and remained in custody. A hearing on November 4 brought Assistant Field Office Director Nichole Black to testify. She stated that she had received instructions from Rasper, passed through Deputy Field Office Director George Valdez, to re-detain habeas petitioners who had “some type of criminality.” Black acknowledged awareness of the release order and believed that taking Alvarez to a public area before arresting him again fulfilled the court’s requirement. However, the court found that the information Black relied on regarding pending criminal charges against Alvarez was incorrect. The court also noted that the government had not made any effort to explain why Alvarez’s petition should not be granted and his release ordered.

Judge Sweeney then ordered Alvarez’s release by 2:00 p.m. on November 4. A status report was required within an hour of his release, and the respondents were ordered to produce Rasper for a further evidentiary hearing scheduled for November 9. The number of cases involving immediate re-detention after a court-ordered release had risen from approximately ten to eighteen by this time.

See also  Jury Awards Boeing $49.5 Million in 737 MAX Crash Verdict

On November 9, Rasper testified that he had ordered an end to the practice. He also stated that individuals who had been rearrested under this policy would be released. Rasper assured the court that a habeas petitioner ordered released would not be immediately detained again. He further testified that if ICE identified issues with a petitioner’s habeas request, these would be presented to the court within the seven-day period outlined in a memorandum of agreement. The court noted that the district and the U.S. Attorney’s Office had agreed to carry out habeas releases in accordance with court orders.

What the Court Found and the Case’s Outcome

The contempt order issued on November 18 found Black and the government respondents in contempt of the October 20 order. This contempt was specifically for the period from Alvarez’s immediate re-detention on October 27 until the practice stopped on November 9. Civil contempt is a court’s finding that a party has failed to obey a court order. It generally requires clear and convincing evidence that a valid order was in place, that the respondent was aware of it, and that the respondent disobeyed it.

Since the respondents ceased the practice of immediate re-detention, the judge chose not to impose further penalties. Alvarez had already been released, leading the court to deny his remaining motions as moot, meaning they were no longer relevant to the case. The clerk was directed to close the case. Court documents and the case docket are available online for public access.

Frequently Asked Questions

What does it mean for ICE to be found in contempt of court?
Who is a habeas petitioner?

A habeas petitioner is someone who asks a court to review if their detention is legal.

Why was ICE re-detaining people after a court ordered their release?

ICE officials implemented a policy to review cases for potential criminal charges before releasing individuals, even after a court order.

Advertisements
What is the outcome of the contempt finding?

Because ICE stopped the practice and the individual was released, the judge did not impose further penalties and the case was closed.

Posted in: Visa

Related Posts

Conversation

0 Comments

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Thanks for watching! Content unlocked for this session.