Judge Finds ICE in Contempt Over Colorado Re-Arrest
A U.S. District Judge has found Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) and the federal government in contempt of court. This decision came after a man was re-arrested shortly after a judge ordered his release. The ruling highlights a practice where individuals ordered released by a court were immediately detained again by ICE.
The case involved Ramon Quintero Alvarez, who had been in immigration detention since February 2026. He sought a writ of habeas corpus, a legal process to challenge the lawfulness of his detention. When the government failed to provide sufficient cause for his continued detention by October 27, 2026, he was ordered released. However, ICE officers re-arrested him just outside the detention center.
The Contempt Ruling
On November 18, 2026, U.S. District Judge Charlotte Sweeney declared ICE and the federal government in contempt. Contempt of court means that a party has disobeyed a court’s order or authority. Judge Sweeney’s decision was based on the re-arrest of Ramon Quintero Alvarez immediately after a court had mandated his release.
What the Ruling Means for Detained Individuals
The judge imposed no further sanctions because ICE officials provided a sworn assurance. They stated that the Denver ICE office had stopped the practice of immediate re-arrests following court-ordered releases. This assurance was the basis for the judge’s decision to decline further action, though she noted the matter could be reopened if court orders are violated again.
This means that for immigrants in Colorado who are ordered released by a federal court, the assurance of no immediate re-arrests is legally binding. However, a spokesperson for the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) clarified that a court-ordered release does not prevent ICE from pursuing a later arrest, as long as it complies with the court’s decision.
Background of Alvarez’s Case
Alvarez, who was born in Mexico, entered the United States with his mother between 1993 and 1994 and has lived in the country since. He stated he had lived in Wyoming for 12 years and has two American-born sons. The federal government did not dispute his account during the court hearing. His attempt to gain release through a writ of habeas corpus was successful when the government could not justify his continued detention.
ICE Officials’ Statements on Re-arrests
During a hearing on November 4, 2026, ICE assistant field office director Nichole Black testified about an instruction to re-detain individuals with “some type of criminality.” She stated this instruction originated from deputy field office director George Valdez, who had received it from acting Denver field office director Nathan Rasper.
Rasper testified on November 9, 2026, explaining he had heard from ICE colleagues in Minnesota about re-arresting individuals after court-ordered releases. He claimed he had told officials to consult ICE lawyers before making any subsequent arrests to ensure their lawfulness. Rasper admitted his instructions were not clear and that Black may have misunderstood them. Following Black’s testimony, Rasper stated he halted the immediate re-arrest practice and directed the release of individuals detained under that policy. He then reaffirmed under oath that the Denver office had ceased this practice.
The Judge’s Findings and Future Implications
Judge Sweeney found that ICE had a pattern of releasing individuals as ordered by the court, only to re-detain them moments later in public areas outside the detention facility. In the six weeks leading up to the ruling, at least 18 people in Colorado were either held longer than they should have been or re-arrested within minutes of a court-ordered release.
The judge wrote that this practice “made a mockery of court orders mandating petitioners’ immediate release.” She emphasized that court orders and judgments must be followed promptly. Rasper’s sworn statement that the practice had stopped was the primary reason she chose not to impose further penalties. However, Judge Sweeney made it clear that she could reopen the case if there are any future violations of judicial orders, which could lead to more severe consequences for the officials involved.
Frequently Asked Questions
What does it mean for ICE to be found in contempt of court?
Being found in contempt of court means that ICE and the federal government disobeyed a direct order from the judge or undermined the court’s authority.
Why was ICE found in contempt in this case?
ICE was found in contempt because they re-arrested Ramon Quintero Alvarez immediately after a judge had ordered his release from immigration detention.
What is a writ of habeas corpus?
A writ of habeas corpus is a legal action that allows a person to challenge the lawfulness of their detention, essentially asking a court to review why they are being held.
Does this ruling mean ICE can never re-arrest someone after a court orders their release?
No, ICE stated that a court-ordered release does not prevent them from pursuing a later arrest, as long as it is done in compliance with the court’s decision and not immediately after the release order.

Conversation
0 Comments