Judge Considers Refugee Status Challenge, No Ruling Issued
On November 20, 2026, a federal judge heard arguments regarding a challenge to policies affecting refugees. U.S. District Judge Myong J. Joun considered motions in the case Partnership for the Advancement of New Americans v. Edlow. While the judge took the motions under advisement, meaning he will review them before making a decision, no ruling was issued at the hearing. This leaves in place a hold on refugee green card applications and a separate pause on a rule that shortens the time refugees have to respond to potential termination of their status.
Policies Affecting Refugees Under Review
The lawsuit challenges several policies that impact refugees. These include a hold on processing green card applications for refugees, a review process for refugees admitted under a previous administration, and a rule that would reduce the response period for potential termination of refugee status from 30 days to 10 days. The court’s pause on the shortened response rule is distinct from the hold on green card applications.
Refugees with pending green card applications are affected by the application hold. Their applications will remain on hold while the court considers the case. For refugees who receive a notice that the government intends to terminate their status, a separate pause on the 10-day response rule is in effect until December 4, 2026. During this period, these refugees may still be given a 30-day window to respond. The shortened rule specifically targets refugees whom U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) determines were not eligible for refugee status when they were admitted to the United States.
Plaintiffs’ Requests to the Court
The plaintiffs in the case, which include six refugee advocacy organizations and four individual refugees from various countries, asked the judge to take several actions. Their motions requested that the court pause the challenged policies while the lawsuit proceeds. They also sought to have the case certified as a class action, allowing it to represent a larger group of people with similar legal claims. Additionally, the plaintiffs asked for permission to use pseudonyms in the court filings. A request for a stay, as allowed under 5 U.S.C. § 705, is a formal request for a court to postpone agency actions during a review.
Arguments Presented in Court
During the hearing, Judge Joun raised questions about the government’s ability to indefinitely halt refugee green card application processing. He also expressed difficulty understanding the rationale behind a 10-day response period, comparing it to the time needed to renew a dog license, which he noted takes about 45 days. The plaintiffs argued that the application hold and the re-vetting policy lack legal basis. They also contended that the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) should have sought public comment before shortening the response period. Lawyers for the plaintiffs stated that over 100,000 refugees could be negatively impacted by these policies.
Representing the federal government, Assistant U.S. Attorney Vincent Engingro defended the policies as necessary security measures. He argued that past vetting processes were not strict enough, potentially allowing individuals who should not have been admitted to enter the country. Engingro emphasized the importance of acting quickly when it is determined that someone is not entitled to refugee status.
Background of the Case
The policies in question were initiated by a memo from USCIS Director Joseph Edlow on November 21, 2025. This memo ordered a halt to refugee green card applications and a review of refugees admitted during the preceding administration. The lawsuit was filed on October 26, 2026, by the organizations and refugees seeking relief from these measures. The court scheduled the hearing for November 20, 2026, after the government filed its opposition to the plaintiffs’ requests and the plaintiffs submitted their reply.
Next Steps in the Legal Process
Judge Joun has not yet issued a decision on the motions presented. The temporary pause on the 10-day termination rule is expected to continue through December 4, 2026. Meanwhile, the hold on green card applications remains in effect as the court reviews the case.
Frequently Asked Questions
What policies are being challenged in the lawsuit?
The lawsuit challenges a hold on processing refugee green card applications, a review of refugees admitted under a previous administration, and a rule that shortens the response time for potential termination of refugee status from 30 days to 10 days.
What is the current status of refugee green card applications?
There is a hold on processing refugee green card applications, and they will remain on hold while the court considers the case.
What is the temporary pause on the termination rule?
A separate pause is in effect on the rule that shortens the response period for potential termination of refugee status to 10 days. This pause lasts until December 4, 2026, and refugees may still be given a 30-day window to respond during this time.
When were these policies put in place?
The policies in question were initiated by a memo from USCIS Director Joseph Edlow on November 21, 2025.

Conversation
0 Comments