Deportees in South Sudan Face Hardship Amidst Custody Disputes
Five individuals deported from the United States are currently held in South Sudanese custody, with their families reporting dire conditions and allegations of mistreatment by guards. These deportees, who arrived in South Sudan in July 2025, have been in detention for over a year. While the South Sudanese Foreign Ministry states it is working towards their repatriation and denies claims of mistreatment, families of the deportees paint a different picture, describing a lack of adequate food and water and guards pocketing money sent for their loved ones.
Families Allege Mistreatment and Financial Exploitation
Families of the five deportees claim that guards have been demanding money with promises of improving the detainees’ living conditions. However, these promises have allegedly gone unfulfilled, with the money being kept by the guards while the deportees suffer from a lack of basic necessities. One family member, Ngoc Phan, reported sending approximately USD 4,000 for her husband, Tuan Phan, intended for food, water, and a cellphone. Tuan Phan stated he lost a significant amount of weight, around 20 pounds, during his detention in a facility in Juba.
These accounts suggest a serious breakdown in the care and management of individuals in state custody, raising questions about accountability and the humane treatment of deportees. The situation highlights the potential for abuse when individuals are left in a legal and logistical limbo after deportation.
South Sudan’s Foreign Ministry Denies Allegations
In contrast to the families’ claims, South Sudan’s Foreign Ministry has issued a statement denying that the deportees are mistreated. The ministry asserts that the detainees are provided with sufficient food, water, and medical care, all of which are funded by the government. They also state that the deportees have regular opportunities to communicate with their relatives and legal representatives.
Furthermore, the ministry emphasized that the United States has “fully relinquished responsibility and no longer has any legal jurisdiction over, or ties to, these individuals.” This statement underscores the complex legal status of the deportees, who are no longer under U.S. jurisdiction but remain in South Sudanese custody without a clear path forward for all of them. The ministry maintains that efforts are underway to facilitate their safe and humane repatriation.
The Journey to Detention
The case of these five deportees is part of a larger group of eight men who were sent to South Sudan in July 2025 following a legal process that concluded with a Supreme Court decision. At the time of their arrival, former border czar Tom Homan stated that these individuals were no longer in U.S. custody. However, the subsequent detention and reported conditions have raised significant concerns.
Two individuals from the original group have since been repatriated. Tuan Thanh Phan returned to Vietnam in June 2026 after nearly a year in detention in Juba. Thongxay Nilakout departed for Laos in October 2026, also after more than a year in custody. The continued detention of the remaining five deportees, coupled with the allegations from their families, points to ongoing challenges in resolving their cases and ensuring their well-being.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the main concerns for deportees held in South Sudan?
Families report that deportees are facing harsh conditions, including lack of adequate food and water, and alleged mistreatment and financial exploitation by guards.
Does the South Sudanese government acknowledge the mistreatment claims?
No, the South Sudanese Foreign Ministry denies the allegations, stating that the detainees are provided with sufficient food, water, and medical care funded by the government.
What happened to the other deportees who arrived with this group?
Out of an initial group of eight, two individuals have since been repatriated to their home countries: Tuan Thanh Phan returned to Vietnam in June 2026, and Thongxay Nilakout departed for Laos in October 2026.
What is the legal status of these deportees?
The deportees are no longer under U.S. jurisdiction, but they remain in South Sudanese custody. The U.S. has stated it has no further legal responsibility for them.

Conversation
0 Comments