Skip to content
Open menu
Toggle search

American Oversight Sues DHS for Voter Initiative Records

Share

American Oversight Sues DHS for Voter Initiative Records

SA Portal

SA Portal

Published
Share

American Oversight Sues DHS Over Unlawful Voter Initiative Records

American Oversight has filed a lawsuit against the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) and U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS). The lawsuit, filed on November 11, 2026, seeks to compel these agencies to release records related to an alleged “Unlawful Voter Initiative.” The watchdog group is asking a federal court to order the agencies to speed up the processing of six public records requests and to provide documents detailing how officials have been reviewing voter information.

Advertisements

These requests are important because the records could clarify how federal officials investigate claims of noncitizen voting and what safeguards are in place to protect eligible voters. If records lead to mistaken flags, it could affect voters. The lawsuit also concerns state election offices and federal employees involved in these reviews. DHS denied American Oversight’s request for expedited processing and claimed an extension, while USCIS has not yet responded to the requests. Neither agency has released any records to date.

Lawsuit Targets Initiative Rules and Data Handling

The six Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) requests were initially filed on September 16, 2026. The lawsuit aims to have a court order the agencies to process these requests quickly and release the relevant documents. The requests focus on five main areas:

Advertisements

Subscribe for updates

Get new posts, insights, and occasional updates delivered to your inbox.

We respect your privacy.

  • Communications from Senior Officials: This includes emails from high-ranking officials at DHS and USCIS, such as Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin, Deputy Secretary Troy Edgar, Senior Counselor Heather Honey, and Joseph Edlow. The search terms used in these requests include phrases like “unlawful voter,” “voter fraud,” “state voter,” “voter record,” “FDNS enhancement,” and “overtime.”
  • Training Materials: The requests seek training materials for personnel within USCIS’s Fraud Detection and National Security Directorate. This also includes a video that was reportedly shown around August 21, 2026.
  • Review Quotas: Information about any quotas or specific targets set for the number of individuals officers were expected to review is also being sought.
  • Inter-Agency Communications: This category covers communications between USCIS and election offices in 19 different states and the District of Columbia, dating back to July 1, 2026.
  • Data Sources and Software: The requests ask for details about the sources and types of data that officers received. They also seek information about any matching or data-mining software used in the process.
See also  Thailand Shortens Visa-Free Stays for 93 Countries to 30 Days

American Oversight has stated that it is not seeking the voter data itself. Instead, the organization wants to understand the operational procedures and protections in place. Chioma Chukwu, American Oversight’s executive director, emphasized the public’s right to know: “The public deserves to see the rules, the data, and the quotas behind this operation and know what safeguards are in place to protect eligible voters.”

Whistleblower Allegations of Rushed Reviews

A letter sent in September to DHS and USCIS by Senators Alex Padilla and Chuck Schumer included a disclosure from a whistleblower. This whistleblower reportedly claimed that officers in the Fraud Detection and National Security Directorate were reassigned to examine data for supposed “unlawful voters.” The disclosure also alleged that USCIS employees were instructed to misrepresent themselves to gain access to state voter records, which American Oversight notes could violate state laws.

The whistleblower further alleged that officers were required to review at least five subjects per hour, totaling 40 per day. This pace leaves approximately 12 minutes for each person’s review. Such a high volume of work could potentially lead to increased errors, and the whistleblower indicated that officers were unsure about the origin of the voter data they were using. It is important to note that these are allegations made in the disclosure and not established facts in the current FOIA case. Research has consistently shown that noncitizen voting is rare.

Agencies’ Lack of Response

American Oversight reported that DHS responded to their requests on October 17, 2026, about a month after they were filed. The department denied the request for expedited processing and stated it needed an extension to respond. According to American Oversight, DHS has not communicated further with them since that response.

See also  Alaska Airlines Flight 528 Executes Go-Around at SFO Due to Runway Obstruction

USCIS, on the other hand, had not responded to any of the five requests submitted to it, including the requests for expedited processing. By the time American Oversight announced its lawsuit on November 11, neither agency had released any records. If the lawsuit is successful, the requested documents could become available to election officials and the public, shedding light on federal investigation methods and safeguards against wrongly flagging eligible voters.

Broader Federal Review of Voter Files

Records obtained by Democracy Forward suggest a wider federal review of voter files. These records indicate that Heather Honey acquired 48.4 million records from independent sources, while investigators examined 50.6 million records from the Justice Department. Homeland Security Investigations reportedly monitored recent primary elections for potential vulnerabilities that could impact election integrity.

In a separate legal action, voting-rights and privacy groups are challenging DHS’s possession of voter records from at least 47 states, which cover a significant portion of the nation’s 174 million registered voters. These groups are seeking to halt the collection and use of this data and have it deleted, arguing that the Privacy Act and federal system-of-records notice requirements apply. These claims are distinct from the current FOIA case.

DHS has stated that its handling of publicly available voter files has been transparent. The department has described its enforcement focus as: “DHS and DOJ are laser focused on prosecuting and removing aliens who vote and preventing the dilution of the votes of US citizens.” Another instance of federal voter-record reviews involves a dispute between the Justice Department and California. In October 2026, the U.S. government provided California with a list of over 20,000 individuals it believed were noncitizens registered for a federal election, requesting a review within 48 hours.

Past Claims by Secretary Mullin

Earlier in 2026, Secretary Mullin made claims about noncitizens registered to vote. At a news conference on July 17, he stated that the department had identified 250,000 noncitizens registered to vote in California, New Jersey, Nevada, and Pennsylvania. He provided specific figures for each state: 190,832 for California, 35,152 for New Jersey, 15,903 for Nevada, and 14,576 for Pennsylvania. American Oversight noted that Mullin did not provide supporting evidence for these numbers at the time. A White House official indicated that the estimate originated from commercial databases and relied on data without unique identifiers like driver’s license or Social Security numbers.

See also  Global Airlines Ltd Ordered into Liquidation by High Court

DHS publicly stated that more than 250,000 noncitizens were “illegally registered to vote.” However, Mullin’s letters to state officials used more cautious language, such as “may be as many as.” In Nevada, DHS sent state officials a smaller list of 185 individuals it claimed were confirmed non-U.S. citizens. According to American Oversight, Nevada informed DHS on September 22 that all 185 individuals on that list were, in fact, U.S. citizens. The group also pursued legal action regarding the basis for the four-state estimate. Previously, with the Campaign Legal Center, they sought records concerning DHS’s modifications to the SAVE system, which uses federal data to identify potential noncitizens on state voter rolls.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the main reason American Oversight is suing DHS and USCIS?

American Oversight is suing to get records about an alleged “Unlawful Voter Initiative” and to force the agencies to process their public records requests faster.

What kind of information is American Oversight seeking?

They are looking for communications from senior officials, training materials, information on review quotas, communications with state election offices, and details about data sources and software used in reviewing voter information.

What concerns have been raised by whistleblowers?

Whistleblowers have alleged that USCIS employees were told to misrepresent themselves to get voter records and were given very high quotas for reviewing potential noncitizens, which could lead to errors.

Advertisements
Have DHS or USCIS provided any records yet?

No, as of the lawsuit filing, neither agency had released any records. DHS claimed an extension, and USCIS had not responded at all.

Posted in: Visa

Related Posts

Conversation

0 Comments

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Thanks for watching! Content unlocked for this session.